Specialty, Handmade Cookies
If you're tired of looking at sad, unoriginal cookies in the grocery store then you're in the right place. Baked By Mary's baked goods are unique culinary creations with a focus on quality, creative cookies. As a bonus, we bake all our cookies in Ankeny, Iowa.
Current Pickup Cookies
Every month, Mary cooks up a least one lineup of cleverly curated cookies at a slightly reduced price so everyone can enjoy them and share with friends. It's simple! You order some cookies and then on pickup day you come get your order.
Special Order Cookies
Does the monthly order pickup date not work for your schedule or are none of the cookies in the lineup tickling your fancy? No problem! Check out full catalog of cookies, find something you like and then submit your email with the special order form. We'll connect with you from there!
Blueberry Muffin
$25.00 / dozen
Pumpkin Pie
$30.00 / dozen
Butter Beer
$25.00 / dozen
Halloween Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Candy Corn Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Buckeye
$25.00 / dozen
Sunflower Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Peanut Butter & Jelly
$25.00 / dozen
Back To School Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
July 4th Birthday
$25.00 / dozen
July 4th Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Monster
$25.00 / dozen
Frosted Lemon
$25.00 / dozen
Pineapple Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Orange Creamsicle
$25.00 / dozen
Caramel Coconut & Chocolate
$25.00 / dozen
Churro
$25.00 / dozen
Flower Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Cookies & Cream
$25.00 / dozen
Easter Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Carrot Cake
$25.00 / dozen
Dirt Cake
$25.00 / dozen
Key Lime
$30.00 / dozen
French Silk
$30.00 / dozen
Banana Cream
$30.00 / dozen
Valentine's Day Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Valentine's Day Brownie
$25.00 / dozen
Cream Cheese Frosted Almond
$25.00 / dozen
Chocolate Overload
$25.00 / dozen
Frosted Gingerbread
$25.00 / dozen
Cookie Dough
$25.00 / dozen
Butter Frosted Maple Waffle
$25.00 / dozen
Banana Bread
$25.00 / dozen
Pumpkin Coffee Cake
$25.00 / dozen
Winter Sugar
$25.00 / dozen
Cream-Filled Chocolate
$25.00 / dozen
Frosted Cinnamon Roll
$25.00 / dozen
Raspberry Cheesecake
$25.00 / dozen
German Chocolate Cake
$25.00 / dozen
Frosted Snickerdoodle
$25.00 / dozen
Apple Pie
$30.00 / dozen